Dear Family and Friends,
For over three months, I’ve been hesitant as to whether or not to publish my thoughts on this topic. It’s personal, painful and very sad for the 15 families of Netiv Avot, a neighborhood of Elazar, who will be evicted from their houses on March 6, 2018.
This is occurring right here, less than a mile from my house, in my community. It’s not personal only because it is in my community, but specifically because Liron, my grandson Amir’s wife is personally involved.
The story begins in 2000. Liron’s family and three other families decided to leave their comfortable homes in Elazar and to move to a trailer, (a caravan), up to a hill that overlooks Elazar. Why did they decide to do such an insane act?
During the years of 2000 – 2005 there was an intifada in all of Israel. During that time there were shootings and other acts of violence. Rocks were thrown from the hills that surround Elazar and on to the main road between Elazar and Efrat. The hill that Liron’s parents moved to was a strategic point because it lies in the center of Gush Etzion. Everyone knew that controlling that hill was crucial in the defense of the yishuv. That was the motivation of the four families who moved there to guarantee that the hill would remain in Jewish hands.
During those years, the government supported this community by giving security, electricity, water and infrastructure. But more importantly, the government promised these families and others that moved there, that the land will be approved for Jewish occupancy.
Meanwhile, the leftist organizations of Israel, like Shalom Achshav, Peace Now, have been trying to convince Arabs to apply a lawsuit to the Supreme Court, trying to show that the land belongs to them. Until today, even after 3 three hearings at the Supreme Court, there is no proof of evidence that the land belongs to those Arabs contesting this land. Even though there is no proof, the Supreme Court has decided to destroy 15 out of 42 homes, because satellite footage from 1963 allegedly shows that there are very small strips of land, 3′ to 12′ worked by an unknown Arab, that cut through the houses. Some strips of land go through the house and some strips only touch corners of the houses, as you can see in the photograph below.

In the picture above, the land in the blue areas belong to the State of Israel and the narrow strips of brown land within in the blue, are lands that don’t have a clear ownership. On March 6, 2018 the homes are to be destroyed. The Supreme Court has denied a request that only the corners of the homes be destroyed and has insisted that the entire structure be torn down.
Below, is another picture depicting the disputed land.

This unfortunately as sad as it is, is really a statement as to the dynamic that is occurring in the State of Israel. There is a battle going on between the Executive and the Judicial as to who is responsible for legislating the laws of the country. It is a further battle between the right and the left and between those who have chosen to live in Yehudah and Shomrom, and against those who still maintain that we are only “settlers” in an occupied land that we have no right to. Worst of all, it is a description of the operations of the government who have consistently promised that they would resolve this issue and guarantee the rights of those who live in that area and who have consistently gone back on their words and on their promises. I should point out that that area Netiv Avot, Path of our Fathers, marks the place where our forefathers once walked and lived so many years ago.
The link below was made by the residents of Netiv Avov about the impending destruction. It has English subtitles and the man representing the group is Ami Gvirtzman, Liron’s father.
https://m.giveback.co.il/?id=2556#/main?id=2556
There are 15 families and 65 children that will be homeless unless the government will find a solution for them. All these procedures between the families and the government and between the families and the Supreme Court, take thousands of dollars in fees for lawyers, advertising and the right to protest.
Driving into Elazar these days, is a shocking sight. The government is fearful of attempting to come into the yishuv in order to accomplish their mission. They have therefore opted to build a new back road into the area so that they can bypass the main part of the yishuv. Ironically, that road cuts through Arab land, but no one seems to care. In addition, there are members of Shalom Achshav and other organizations who visit the site frequently to make sure that this goal of displacement will be carried out. Jew against Jew, Jew against the country, Jew against the government, another scenario from Gush Katif happening again.
Below are pictures I took from the top of Netiv Avot showing the wide road they are building to reach Netiv Avot from the main road. The first picture shows vehicles travelling on Road 60. Road 60 is the road that travels from the Gush north to Jerusalem or south to Hebron and Be’ir Sheva. In the distance is Efrat. The second picture shows the road in construction.

Road 60

Road to destruction
Please find the most recent article that addresses itself to this catastrophe. Clearly there will be many more such articles as we get closer to the March 6th deadline.
https://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/241990
As I said at the start, I am clearly biased in this matter. These people are my neighbors, machatanim and friends. I have tried to present the facts as they are, but this is after all the third such evacuation occurring this year. Had the government told the people not to occupy this land and their homes then it would have been a different story. And even though one could argue that they knew that they were taking a chance by moving there, they were encouraged to do so with the granting of a total infrastructure.
May we only hear good news as we enter into Adar, the month of joy and happiness.
Shavua Tov
Vivien Well
PS Our grandchildren, Amir and Liron asked that those who wish to financially help these families are encouraged to do so. The link is below and there is an option for English in the top left corner.
HeadStart is an organization for “recruiting the masses,” which will double the total amount of money submitted, only if the end goal is reached. If not, all the money will be returned to the donors. There are only 12 days left to donate to HeadStart.
https://m.giveback.co.il/?id=2556#/main?id=2556
In advance, we thank you for your help.




















~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~










